As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more about our affiliate disclaimer.
Grilling plank vs grilling stone is about flavor versus reuse. A soaked cedar plank gently steams and smokes fish and veggies, adding woody flavor, but it is used once or a few times. A grilling stone gives steady, even heat for fish, flatbread and pizza and lasts for years.
Here are both, plus how to use them.

Quick Answer: The Grilling Plank vs Grilling Stone
- Best Cedar PlanksOld Mill Trading Co. Western Red Cedar 5 x 12 in. Grilling Planks
- Best Grilling StoneWeber Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with Carry Rack, 16.7 in.
- Best Value PlanksWestern Cedar Grilling Planks, 12 Pack
- Best Budget StoneCuisinart CPS-013 Alfrescamore Pizza Grilling Stone
- Best Small PlanksEast Coast Cedar Small Planks for Grilling Salmon, Made in USA
- Best Stone TilesOutset Pizza Grill Stone Tiles, Set of 4
Choose cedar planks for salmon and delicate fish when you want smoky aroma with little effort. Choose a grilling stone for repeat use, pizza and flatbread, and for searing small foods without flare-ups. Soak planks at least an hour, and preheat stones slowly with the grill.
Grilling Plank vs Grilling Stone Comparison Table
| Product | Best For | Type | Key Feature | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Old Mill Western Red Cedar | Best Cedar Planks | Cedar grilling planks | 5 x 12 in. western red cedar | Check Price |
| Weber Gourmet BBQ Pizza Stone | Best Grilling Stone | Kettle pizza stone | Stone sized for Weber Gourmet grates | Check Price |
| Western Cedar Planks 12 Pack | Best Value Planks | Cedar grilling planks | Twelve cedar planks for salmon and veggies | Check Price |
| Cuisinart Alfrescamore Stone | Best Budget Stone | Grill pizza stone | Stone with a metal carrying frame | Check Price |
| East Coast Cedar Small Planks | Best Small Planks | Cedar grilling planks | Smaller planks for single fillets | Check Price |
| Outset Stone Tiles | Best Stone Tiles | Cordierite tiles | Four tiles for flexible layouts | Check Price |
Our 6 Top Grilling Planks and Stones
Cedar planks and grill stones.
1. Old Mill Trading Co. Western Red Cedar 5 x 12 in. Grilling Planks
1. Old Mill.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Classic cedar aroma
- Good size for two fillets
- Untreated wood (maker)
Cons
- Single use for most cooks
- Must soak first
📄 Detailed Review
- Wood: Western red cedar
- Size: 5 x 12 in.
- Use: Salmon, veggies
Classic western red cedar planks.
Our top pick.
2. Weber Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with Carry Rack, 16.7 in.
2. Weber Gourmet.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Made for Weber grates
- Rack makes moving it safer
- Even bake
Cons
- Needs a Gourmet BBQ System grate to sit flush
- No heat dome
📄 Detailed Review
- Diameter: 16.7 in.
- Material: Ceramic stone
- Extra: Carry rack
Weber’s own stone for kettles with the Gourmet grate.
Best Weber fit.
3. Western Cedar Grilling Planks, 12 Pack
3. 12 pack.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Classic smoky cedar flavor
- Many planks per pack
- Great for salmon
Cons
- Single or few uses each
- Needs soaking time
📄 Detailed Review
- Wood: Western red cedar (listing)
- Pieces: 12
- Use: Soak before grilling
A value pack of cedar planks.
Best value planks.
4. Cuisinart CPS-013 Alfrescamore Pizza Grilling Stone
4. Cuisinart.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Frame makes it easier to move
- Made for grills
- Compact
Cons
- Smaller cooking area
- Frame adds bulk
📄 Detailed Review
- Size: About 13 in. (listing)
- Use: Grill and oven (listing)
- Extra: Metal frame (listing)
Cuisinart’s grill stone with frame.
Cuisinart grill stone.
5. East Coast Cedar Small Planks for Grilling Salmon, Made in USA
5. Made in USA.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Portion-sized planks
- Good for small grills
- US-made claim
Cons
- Small for whole sides of fish
- Single use
📄 Detailed Review
- Wood: Cedar (listing)
- Size: Small (listing)
- Made in: USA (listing)
Small cedar planks for fillets.
Best small planks.
6. Outset Pizza Grill Stone Tiles, Set of 4
6. Outset 4.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Fits odd-size ovens
- Less likely to crack as one piece
Cons
- Seams between tiles
- Tiles can shift
📄 Detailed Review
- Pieces: 4 tiles
- Use: Oven and grill
- Brand: Outset
Four smaller tiles you can arrange to fit your oven.
Good for unusual oven sizes.
How We Chose the Grilling Plank vs Grilling Stone
For this grilling plank vs grilling stone guide, we compared grill pans, griddles, planchas, mats, planks and grilling stones listed on Amazon US by material, size, heat limits, fuel type, care and price, using product details from the listings and makers rather than a hands-on lab test. We then looked at common praise and complaints in buyer feedback for sear quality, sticking, warping, cleanup and durability. Prices and listings change often, so check the current listing before you buy.
Use heat-rated gloves, keep mats under the maker heat limit, cook poultry to 165°F, ground meat to 160°F and steaks to 145°F with a 3-minute rest, and follow USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service cleanliness guidance for kitchen hygiene. Our method is explained on the How We Test page.
Grilling Plank vs Grilling Stone: Key Differences
Flavor
Planks add smoke and aroma; stones add none.
Reuse
Planks are single or few uses; stones last years.

Prep
Soak planks; preheat stones gradually.
Best foods
Planks: salmon, veggies. Stones: pizza, flatbread, fish.
Safety
Keep a spray bottle for plank flare-ups; use gloves for hot stones.
Tips for Better Grilling
- Preheat surfaces fully before cooking.
- Oil the food, not the grill.
- Keep a two-zone fire for control.
- Use a thermometer for doneness.
- Clean grates while warm.

Quick answers to common questions about grilling plank vs grilling stone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a cedar plank or grilling stone better for salmon?
A plank for smoke flavor, a stone for a seared crust.
Can cedar planks be reused?
Sometimes, if only lightly charred.
Do I need to soak a grilling stone?
No, never; soak only wood planks.
What temperature for fish?
Cook fish to 145°F.
Final Verdict
In grilling plank vs grilling stone, cedar planks win on flavor and the Weber stone wins on reuse and pizza.
Related Guides
Keep exploring grilling gear with these guides:
Prices and availability change often. Check the current listing on Amazon before you buy.






