As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more about our affiliate disclaimer.
The best ice mold for old fashioned cocktails makes one large cube or sphere that fills the glass, chills the drink and melts slowly. A 2-inch clear cube is the bar standard, but cloudy large cubes still work well at home.
We compared six molds on Amazon US by size, clarity and reviews.
Quick Answer: The Best Ice Mold for Old Fashioned
- Best OverallCrystal Clear Ice Cube Maker, 4 Large 2 x 2 x 2 in. Cubes
- Best Large-Cube TrayW&P Peak Silicone Extra Large Cube Ice Tray with Protective Lid
- Best Cheap SpheresTovolo Sphere Ice Mold Set of 2
- Best Clear SpheresCrystal Clear Ice Ball Maker, 4 Cavity 2.5 in. Spheres
- Best Budget CubesGGOW Big Silicone Ice Cube Trays, 2 Inch, Huge Square Cubes
- Best Budget ClearFDDBI 2 Inch Clear Ice Cube Maker, Silicone Large Ice Cube Tray
The Crystal Clear 4-cube maker is our top pick for bar-style clear cubes. The W&P Peak tray is the best large-cube tray, Tovolo spheres are the best cheap spheres, and the clear ice ball maker is best for clear spheres.
Best Ice Mold for Old Fashioned Comparison Table
| Product | Best For | Type | Key Feature | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crystal Clear 4-Cube Maker | Best Overall | Clear ice mold | Directional freezing insulated box | Check Price |
| W&P Peak Extra Large Cube | Best Large-Cube Tray | Large cube tray | Steel-reinforced silicone, lid | Check Price |
| Tovolo Sphere Molds | Best Cheap Spheres | Ice sphere mold | 2.5 in. spheres, funnel fill | Check Price |
| Clear Ice Ball Maker | Best Clear Spheres | Clear ice mold | Directional freezing spheres | Check Price |
| GGOW 2 in. Trays | Best Budget Cubes | Large cube tray | 2 in. cubes, sturdy silicone | Check Price |
| FDDBI Clear Cube Maker | Best Budget Clear | Clear ice mold | Insulated clear-ice tray | Check Price |
The 6 Best Ice Molds for Old Fashioneds
Ranked by look, melt and value.
1. Crystal Clear Ice Cube Maker, 4 Large 2 x 2 x 2 in. Cubes
1. Clear 2 in. cubes.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- About 4,400 ratings, 4.4 average
- Real clear ice
- Simple to use
Cons
- Takes about 24 hours
- Bulky in freezer
📄 Detailed Review
- Cubes: 4
- Size: 2 x 2 x 2 in.
- Method: Directional freezing
An insulated box that freezes from the top down for clear cubes.
Our top clear-ice mold.
2. W&P Peak Silicone Extra Large Cube Ice Tray with Protective Lid
2. Lid.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- About 1,900 ratings, 4.5 average
- Rigid design
- Lid protects from odors
Cons
- Pricier
- Cloudy ice
📄 Detailed Review
- Shape: Square
- Size: Extra large
- Lid: Yes
W&P’s Peak tray is a well-designed large-cube tray with a lid.
Premium pick for big cubes.
3. Tovolo Sphere Ice Mold Set of 2
3. 33,300 ratings.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- About 33,300 ratings, 4.7 average
- Very cheap
- Easy fill
Cons
- Cloudy ice
- Only 2 spheres
📄 Detailed Review
- Shape: Sphere
- Size: About 2.5 in.
- Pieces: 2 molds
Tovolo’s sphere molds are the most-reviewed ice ball molds on Amazon.
The classic starter sphere mold.
4. Crystal Clear Ice Ball Maker, 4 Cavity 2.5 in. Spheres
4. 2.5 in.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- About 1,400 ratings, 4.4 average
- Clear spheres
- Four at once
Cons
- Slow, about a day
- Bulky
📄 Detailed Review
- Shape: Sphere
- Size: 2.5 in.
- Cavities: 4
A directional-freezing box for clear ice balls.
Best for clear spheres.
5. GGOW Big Silicone Ice Cube Trays, 2 Inch, Huge Square Cubes
5. 2 in.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- About 1,700 ratings, 4.6 average
- Sharp edges
- Easy release
Cons
- Cloudy ice
- Smaller batch
📄 Detailed Review
- Shape: Square
- Size: 2 in.
- Material: Silicone
Sturdy large-cube trays with crisp edges.
Nice for old fashioneds.
6. FDDBI 2 Inch Clear Ice Cube Maker, Silicone Large Ice Cube Tray
6. Cheaper clear mold.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- About 760 ratings, 4.2 average
- Cheaper than most clear makers
- Compact
Cons
- Clarity varies
- Mixed reviews
📄 Detailed Review
- Shape: Square
- Size: 2 in.
- Method: Directional freezing
A budget clear-ice tray.
Worth trying before pricier makers.
How We Chose the Best Ice Mold for Old Fashioned
To build this guide to the best ice mold for old fashioned, we compared ice makers, trays and molds sold on Amazon US by cube size and shape, material (silicone, plastic or stainless steel), lids, stacking, freezing method (standard or directional freezing for clear ice) and release. We then read patterns in verified-buyer reviews for clarity, cracking, leaks, odors and ease of release, and flagged listings with few ratings.
Use clean drinking water, wash trays often, and keep ice scoops out of the ice bin, following USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service cleanliness guidance. Our method is explained on the How We Test page; this is a research-based guide, not a lab test.
Buying Guide: Old Fashioned Ice
Size
A 2 in. cube fits a standard rocks glass.
Clarity
Clear ice looks better and melts evenly.
Shape
Cubes are classic; spheres look dramatic.
Temper
Let ice rest a minute to prevent cracking.
Glass
Chill the glass for a colder drink.
Tips for Better Ice
- Use boiled or filtered water for clearer ice.
- Freeze clear ice slowly from the top down.
- Let large cubes temper for a minute before serving to stop cracking.
- Wash silicone trays and store them with lids to avoid freezer odors.
- Store finished cubes in a sealed bag or bin.
Quick answers to common questions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best ice mold for an old fashioned?
A clear 2-inch cube mold.
Cube or sphere for old fashioned?
Either works; cubes are the classic choice.
Does clear ice matter?
It looks better and melts more evenly.
What size ice for old fashioned?
About 2 in.
Final Verdict
Our pick for the best ice mold for old fashioned cocktails is the Crystal Clear 4-cube maker. For a simple tray, choose W&P Peak.
Related Guides
Keep exploring bar gear with these guides:
Prices and availability change often. Check the current listing on Amazon before you buy.
